Phone Call Us 414-326-9231
Toll Free 866-678-9352
Text Us 414-277-7742

Bankruptcy exemptions and fraud allegations, part 1: homestead

Bankruptcy exemptions are very important. They reflect one of the humane elements of bankruptcy: the fact that filing bankruptcy does not have to mean giving up all of your personal possessions.

Though bankruptcy filings are made under federal law, bankruptcy exemptions involve state law and vary by state. Claiming bankruptcy exemptions therefore involves both state and federal law.

In this two-part post, we will discuss a newly decided U.S. Supreme Court case that clarified the use of exemptions in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

The name of the case is Law v. Siegel. It concerned a man from California who filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Chapter 7 is often thought of as a “liquidation” bankruptcy, in contrast to a “reorganization” bankruptcy under Chapter 13.

Even in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, however, exemptions under state law still apply. And so, in Law v. Siegel, the man who filed for Chapter 7 sought to claim a homestead exemption under California law.

Under that exemption, a person filing for bankruptcy is allowed to keep up to $75,000 of the proceeds from the sale of a residence.

The case was made more complicated, though, by an issue concerning liens on the house. The man filing for bankruptcy contended there were two liens on the house and that those liens were greater than the nonexempt value of the house.

If that were the case, there would be no nonexempt proceeds left from the house to be applied to other creditors.

But the bankruptcy trustee asserted that one of the liens on the house was fraudulent. Ultimately, this led to the issue of whether the trustee was permitted to place a “surcharge” on the money from the homestead exemption because of the alleged fraud.

In part two of this post, we will discuss how the Supreme Court resolved the case.

Source: SCOTUSblog, "Opinion analysis: Justices stick with Bankruptcy Code text, rejecting Ninth Circuit's creative punishment of lying bankrupt," Fonald Mann, March 4, 2014

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Our Milwaukee Law Firm

Reach Miller & Miller Law, LLC, online or call us at 414-326-9231 to schedule a free initial consultation. Our law office also provides Spanish language services. Se habla español.

To schedule an initial consultation, call 414-326-9231 or contact Miller & Miller today.

Free Case Evaluation

* indicates required field

Milwaukee Office
633 W Wisconsin Ave, Suite 500
Milwaukee, WI 53203

Phone: 414-326-9231
Phone: 414-312-6581
Fax: 414-277-1303
Milwaukee Law Office Map

Kenosha Office
6123 Green Bay Road
Suite 210
Kenosha, WI 53142

Phone: 414-326-9231
Phone: 262-326-1669
Kenosha Law Office Map

Brookfield Office
200 S. Executive Drive
Suite 101
Brookfield, WI 53005

Phone: 414-326-9231
Phone: 262-261-0665
Brookfield Law Office Map

Madison Office
2810 Crossroads Drive
Suite 4001
Madison, WI 53718

Phone: 414-326-9231
Phone: 608-260-7133
Madison Law Office Map

Glendale Office
6001 N. Green Bay Avenue
Glendale, WI 53209

Phone: 414-326-9231
Phone: 414-973-8662
Glendale Law Office Map

Appleton Office
4321 W. College Ave.
Suite 200
Appleton, WI 54914

Phone: 920-280-3838
Map & Directions