Call Now!
Call Us 414-326-9231 608-260-7133 Text Us 414-326-4709

Will a Wisconsin bankruptcy case define undue hardship? (Cont.)


In our last post, we were discussing the test courts use determine "undue hardship," which is the standard a debtor needs to meet in order to obtain a discharge of a student loan. The Brunner test was developed in the 1980s, and many now consider it out-dated and inappropriate for determining whether a debtor can discharge their student loans.


In the 1980s, Congress and the courts were concerned, wrongly, it turns out, that some individuals were going to graduate, law and medical schools, running up large school loans and then immediately filing for bankruptcy after their graduation. The evidence was largely anecdotal and innuendo, but because of it, student loans joined child support as one of the few categories of debt that cannot be discharged in a bankruptcy.

 The case from Wisconsin shows the absurdity the Brunner test's requirements for undue hardship. The case involves a 57-year-old man, who has had alcohol and mental health issues, has failed to pass the Bar Exam twice, has a partial-MBA and a law degree, and had some criminal charges involving domestic violence tied to his alcohol issues, is unemployed and lives with his 86-year-old mother. And he has $260,000 in student loan debt.

Perhaps the judges need to consider the job market for a 57-year-old man with his background. Any individual that age would face challenges in finding a job, and given his alcohol abuse issues and a criminal record, finding any work beyond minimum wage seems highly optimistic.

A "totality of the circumstances" test would be an improvement, as judges could weigh more elements of a person's situation authorize discharge in cases like this, which seem likely to lead to permanent impoverishment.


Source:, "The Supreme Court May Weigh In on a Student Debt Battle" Natalie Kitroeff, October 19, 2015

The bankruptcy court, the district court and the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals have all found that his situation does not constitute undue hardship under Brunner. A simple loan amortization shows that to repay that debt on a 15-year schedule at a 6% interest rate, or when he would be age 72, he would need to pay almost $2,200 per month, or $26,000 in payments every year. 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Free Case Evaluation

* indicates required field

Miller & Miller Law, LLC
  • VISA
  • Master Cards
  • Discover
Milwaukee Office map Madison Office map Kenosha Office map

633 W Wisconsin Ave, Suite 500
Milwaukee, WI 53203

Phone: 414-312-6581
Fax: 414-277-1303
Milwaukee Office

2810 Crossroads Drive
Suite 4001
Madison, WI 53718

Phone: 608-260-7133
Madison Office

6123 Green Bay Road
Suite 210
Kenosha, WI 53142

Phone: 262-326-1669
Kenosha Office

Appleton Office
4321 W. College Ave.
Suite 200
Appleton, WI 54914

Phone: 920-280-3838
Appleton Office

Brookfield Office
200 S. Executive Drive
Suite 101
Brookfield, WI 53005

Phone: 262-261-0665
Brookfield Office

Glendale Office
6001 N. Green Bay Avenue
Glendale, WI 53209

Phone: 414-973-8662
Glendale Office

Fax: 414-277-1303 - We also have offices in Appleton, Glendale and Brookfield to better serve you.